Amid Scrutiny of NYPD's Sex Crimes Unit, Discipline for Two Former Supervisors

NEW YORK — Two former supervisors in the New York Police Department’s troubled sex-crimes division were disciplined in recent months amid an internal affairs investigation into misconduct by the unit’s leadership, according to department records posted online.

One official, Inspector Paul J. Saraceno, who was second-in-command of the Special Victims Division, was fined 30 vacation days for misusing department time and submitting false time sheets.

The other, Sgt. Keri L. Thompson, who led the division’s DNA cold-case squad and supervised a 2018 investigation of filmmaker Harvey Weinstein, was docked 45 vacation days for misusing a department vehicle and misleading investigators during an interview.

The disciplinary outcomes, which had not previously been reported, came to light following the U.S. Department of Justice’s announcement last week that it had opened a civil rights investigation into whether the police department’s mishandling of sex crime cases amounted to gender-biased policing.

But the cases against Saraceno and Thompson stemmed from an ongoing Internal Affairs Bureau investigation into misconduct at the top of the Special Victims Division that began in 2019, which also focused on accounting for dozens of rape kits that detectives picked up from hospitals in the New York City borough of the Bronx but never turned over to the medical examiner.

Thompson declined to comment when reached by phone Monday, and Saraceno did not respond to a phone call or a text message.

Both pleaded guilty and have been removed from their posts. Thompson was transferred out of the division to patrol after she was served with the charges in late 2020, according to police department records. Saraceno had already left to lead the Vice Enforcement Division — a different unit focused on human trafficking and prostitution — but he was also reassigned to patrol after entering his guilty plea and filed for retirement.

Saraceno was appointed the executive officer of the Special Victims Division in 2017, a selection that made him second only to Chief Michael Osgood, the division commander, just as a city audit was beginning to investigate complaints that the police were not taking rape allegations seriously. After the audit’s findings were made public in 2018, Saraceno was promoted to the inspector rank and given sole responsibility for the adult sex-crimes squads that were the focus of the probe.

By the spring of 2020, before Saraceno was brought up on departmental charges, he was promoted to lead the Vice Enforcement Division, which investigates human trafficking, prostitution and online crimes against children.

He pleaded guilty to three administrative charges: misusing department time, making or causing false entries to be made in department records and failing to submit his weekly timecards on time, according to department records. In addition to the 30 vacation days, he was also fined more than 76 hours of paid leave and six hours of time toward his pension, according to a department personnel record.

Before Thompson was charged by the department, she had supervised Detective Nicholas DiGuadio, whose mistakes in the Weinstein case had led prosecutors to dismiss charges related to one of the movie producer’s accusers.

Thompson pleaded guilty to misusing a department vehicle, making inaccurate or misleading statements to department investigators, failure to supervise and failure to make proper notification to Internal Affairs. Investigators had been looking into how a car assigned to Thompson’s unit wound up so badly damaged that it had to be taken out of service.

Thompson was initially transferred from the Special Victims Division in November 2020, according to the New York Post, after she was charged. She is currently assigned to the 10th Precinct in Manhattan’s Chelsea neighborhood.

Specific details of the misconduct that Saraceno and Thompson admitted to were not publicly available online, and the police department said the information was not readily accessible Monday, citing the July 4 holiday.